Social Media

Why Posting More Isn’t Fixing Your Instagram

January 2, 2026

If you feel like you’re posting more than ever but getting… very little back, you’re not imagining it. More Reels. More Stories. More trends saved.Same reach. Same sales. Same quiet DMs. Here’s the uncomfortable truth most small business owners don’t get told: You don’t have a consistency problem.You have a clarity problem. The myth that’s […]

Travel the world on fifteen damn dollars
Why I don't believe in affiliate marketing
TEN THINGS I ALWAYS HAVE IN MY SUITCASE
Now Trending:
I'm Katy!

Welcome to the side of the internet where content finally gets to feel simple, fun and effective. 

hello,

Want next week's posts done for you?

tell me more

Grab a week of the Content Edit to your inbox for free, right away.

If you feel like you’re posting more than ever but getting… very little back, you’re not imagining it.

More Reels. More Stories. More trends saved.
Same reach. Same sales. Same quiet DMs.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth most small business owners don’t get told:

You don’t have a consistency problem.
You have a clarity problem.

The myth that’s keeping you stuck: “I just need to post more”

Instagram itself doesn’t reward effort — it rewards impact.

Posting daily won’t help if:

  • Every post is trying to do a different job
  • You’re jumping between trends without context
  • You don’t know why you’re posting each thing

In fact, Meta has been pretty clear that Reels, carousels and posts that earn saves, shares and replays now outperform those chasing likes alone. Translation?
👉 Thoughtful > frequent.

What actually moves the needle (especially for small businesses)

From working with both global events and very normal, very busy business owners, the accounts that grow tend to have three things in common:

1. Clear post purpose

Every post has a job.

  • Build trust
  • Solve a problem
  • Show personality
  • Drive visibility

Sometimes a post might do more than that… but have a clear target. One thing you make SURE you nail. The rest is a bonus.

2. Repeatable formats

The algorithm loves familiarity. Humans do too.

When your audience recognises:

  • “Oh, this is one of those posts”
  • “I always save these”
  • “This is helpful / funny / reassuring”

…you start building momentum instead of starting from zero every time.

3. A system, not a scramble

The biggest difference between accounts that feel calm and those that feel chaotic isn’t talent — it’s structure.

People who grow aren’t magically more creative.
They just aren’t reinventing the wheel every Sunday night, or trying to come up with vital content on the fly each day.

Why “post more” advice is so dangerous for small businesses

Because it quietly leads to:

  • Burnout
  • Content resentment
  • A feed full of noise instead of signals

And worst of all?
It makes brilliant business owners think they’re bad at content — when actually, they’ve just never been given a framework.

So what should you do instead?

Post with intent.
Post with balance.
Post with a plan you can repeat.

That’s it. No 30-day challenges. No “go viral or die trying”.

Consistency comes after clarity, not before it.

Inside the membership, we don’t chase more content.
We build a simple weekly structure so you know what’s worth posting, why, and how it fits into the bigger picture — without living on Instagram.

If posting feels heavy right now, it’s not because you’re failing.
It’s because you’ve been told to run without a map.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

so hot right now

I've spent 15+ years in the social media war rooms of some of the biggest brands, from HSBC to the Commonwealth Games, F1 to Nestlé - it's safe to say I know social and content.
I also know that most small businesses don't need another "how to go viral" course. They need someone to show them how to create content that actually converts, without making it your entire life.
I'm a mum of two - a preschooler and a baby - so trust me when I say that I know the whole "I have 17 minutes to make this work!" vibe. But you can - and it can be fun, too.

more about me

Hey! I'm Katy.

Why Posting More Isn’t Fixing Your Instagram (And What Actually Will)

READ IT

BLOG POST

The 4 Types of Content Every Small Business Needs

read it

blog post

Most-Read Resources

Steal a week of social prompts

Get ready-to-post content in your inbox every Friday, so you can tick it off your to-do list without taking up any time.

Send me the friday fix

First Name

Email Address

Social media and content strategy

BLAKE SOCIAL

© BLAKE SOCIAL 2025

Sport
portfolio
the content edit
services
About
Home

SEND ME A NOTE >

GET the friday fix >

@katyelleblake >

follow along 
on Instagram: